Menu of Pomodori Too! in Bluffton, South Carolina, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled on May River Road in Bluffton, Pomodori Too! offers a genuine taste of Italy with a casual, welcoming vibe. This Italian eatery stands out for its thoughtfully crafted menu and fresh, authentic flavors that invite you back again and again. From the moment you enter, the counter-service setup combined with the charming outdoor seating under string lights and the occasional live music makes for a relaxed yet vibrant dining experience.

The menu is anchored by standout dishes that vividly showcase classic Italian culinary techniques with a modern twist. The Gnocchi offers a pillowy, tender bite that pairs beautifully with the house-made sauces, embodying comfort food at its best. Shrimp Francese brings a perfect balance of lightness and zest, with shrimp dipped in a delicate egg batter and sautéed in lemon butter—a dish that tastes as bright and fresh as the South Carolina coastal air.

The Tomato Soup here is not your average starter; it’s rich and velvety with hand-squeezed tomatoes that provide a vibrant acidity, perfectly complemented by a subtle herbal undertone. However, the true centerpiece is unequivocally the Lasagna Bolognese. Scott Milliren’s praise is spot on—this lasagna’s generous 15 layers are a testament to Pomodori Too!’s commitment to bold, hearty flavors. The house-made sausage folded into the meat sauce delivers a savory depth that lingers long after the last bite.

Dishes under the Secondi such as the Shrimp Parm feature hand-squeezed tomatoes, sharp Parmigiano Reggiano, and fresh garlic married with perfectly cooked linguine, creating a harmony of textures and tastes. The Pomodori Special and the Shrimp Milanese with its panko crust, peppery arugula, and lemon accents are further glimpses into the kitchen’s versatility and skill.

For those who enjoy poultry, the Chicken Marsala is a standout—sautéed cremini and portobello mushrooms bathed in a rich marsala wine and butter sauce evoke a rustic Italian countryside ambiance on your plate. Vegetarians will appreciate the Eggplant Milanese, where the panko crust and fresh lemon brighten the palate alongside the sweet cherry tomatoes and red onion.

The Principale pasta offerings reveal the depth of Pomodori Too!’s culinary heart. The Orecchiette with housemade sausage and broccolini boasts a peppery punch from pecorino romano, presenting a pasta course that’s both hearty and fresh. Meanwhile, the Lemon Chicken Angel Hair is a fresh, vibrant dish that combines brightness from sun-dried tomatoes and lemon zest with the creaminess of parmigiano and aromatic basil—perfect for lighter palates.

Customer reviews echo the warmth and authenticity served alongside each dish. Families appreciate the friendly staff and accommodating atmosphere, as noted by Morgan Mcbroom’s heartfelt comment about their staff patiently caring for her daughter. The outdoor ambiance, especially during warmer evenings with live music, creates a memorable setting that elevates the casual dining experience. Don Gray and John Thomas both commend the generous portions and relaxed vibe, perfect for a laid-back meal rather than a formal night out.

Pomodori Too! shines in its ability to marry authentic Italian flavors with attentive, casual service and a charming outdoor setting. It may not offer full-service dining inside yet, but this counter-service gem embraces what dining meant to be—simple, good food served with care. Whether you crave a cheesy lasagna that feels like a labor of love or a refreshing Shrimp Milanese, Pomodori Too! delivers Italian classics with a fresh, heartfelt approach that leaves a lasting impression.